vengefulkyle:
Sure, why not, I’ll take a crack at this nonsense. I don’t dislike Keyleth for existing. I have issue with Keyleth because she brings about confrontation for ridiculous reasons.
Because she never seems to grow as a character and her behavior is almost never informed by past lessons.
Because she has a constant and nonsensical sense of self-loathing for herself and the actions of her companions that brings down any mood and makes her the center of attention.
Because she takes the adverse opinion on almost every situation despite their being no need.
Because despite being a character who is growing out of her shell, she’s constantly showing off.
Because she comes to insane conclusions for the sake of derailing drama, like in the case of her mother’s death and her belief that she’s alive.
These sort of gripes are not because of Keyleth’s gender, they’re because of her behavior, which is grating no matter what she is. If any of the other companions acted this way so often, the reaction would be the same. Vax’s mopiness drove people up a wall until he grew as a character.
This idea that the opinions of a part of a fandom who deride a character are dismissed because of a -perceived and not at all proven- viewpoint that such opinions are painted with outside influences like misogyny is insanity.
this is not the worst post i’ve ever seen about keyleth but it’s fuckin’ up there and i don’t normally respond to shit like this because everybody’s entitled to their opinions but when your opinions are based on entirely incorrect shit, i gotta have a go.
Because she never seems to grow as a character and her behavior is almost never informed by past lessons.
Because despite being a character who is growing out of her shell, she’s constantly showing off.
These are contradictory statements. Make up your mind. Is Keyleth never growing at all or is she slowly growing out of her shell, learning to be a more personable person? Keyleth has one of the biggest character arcs in the game but people assume she didn’t grow or change as a person because her arc was spread out across 115 episodes instead of crammed into a single storyline like Vex or Percy or even Vax’s story. Keyleth grows as a person from being someone who lets the group just walk all over her and being too shy and timid to take a stand about her beliefs into being someone who stands up for what’s right and tries to be a leader – even if she doesn’t always succeed.
And Keyleth doesn’t “show off” as much as she tries to defuse awkward situations by derailing them. This doesn’t work much and I find it a little embarrassing but it’s not “showing off.” Keyleth’s powerful. If you consider any use of her power to be showing off then I don’t know what to tell you. Percy shows off constantly because he’s a vain jackass. Scanlan shows off constantly because he’s a showman at heart. Vax is constantly showing off because he’s OP as hell. Why are you taking issue with Keyleth but not them?
Because she has a constant and nonsensical sense of self-loathing for herself and the actions of her companions that brings down any mood and makes her the center of attention.
Nobody’s ever allowed to have low self-esteem? Keyleth has the weight of her entire tribe on her shoulders and that’s before you get into the stress of being expected to save the world again and again, combined with the fact that she knows she’s fucked up in big ways (killed a kid pre-stream, for one thing) leads to her constantly feeling like she’s unable and unworthy to fulfill all the expectations placed on her.
You might as well argue that Percy’s constant self-derision and insistence that he’s a huge asshole and a monster is him making himself the center of attention and “bringing down the mood.” Or Vax constantly calling himself a fuck up who doesn’t know anything. If you’re not prepared to argue that, maybe you should consider why it bothers you from Keyleth but not Percy or Vax.
Because she takes the adverse opinion on almost every situation despite their being no need.
You mean like all those times that VM is about to do something really morally questionable??? I know a lot of people play D&D like murderhobos who just do whatever they fucking want but Matt’s got a real narrative here and there are consequences to people’s actions. Keyleth has every reason to say “hold on, I don’t think making a deal with the Clasp is a good idea,” because that’s a serious conversation worth having and debating. Or – actually I can’t really think of any other good examples of genuine moral quandaries on the show where Keyleth disagreed with the party?
She was completely correct to be upset about Tiberius hacksawing an old lady and Percy yelling about how someone’s soul is forfeit. Those are fucked up things that happened and the party agreed completely when she brought it up. That’s not an argument or an adverse opinion, that’s “WHOA maybe we should be a little less murderhobo-y, okay guys?” and the party went “Shit, you’re right, our bad.”
Because she comes to insane conclusions for the sake of derailing drama, like in the case of her mother’s death and her belief that she’s alive.
First of all, Keyleth literally didn’t do this. Keyleth didn’t think her mother was alive. She mentioned it was a possibility but she wasn’t actually expecting it to be true (you can tell because Keyleth has very little reaction to the confirmation that her mother is dead) and in fact Marisha pointed out that Keyleth didn’t actually want her mother to be alive (because then there’d be the inevitable question of “why didn’t you come home?”) but didn’t feel comfortable saying that out loud because it was a little fucked up and she knew it.
I’m also not even clear on how that would be “derailing drama” if she had done that. It was her story arc. Surely the bigger drama would have been if her mother had been alive and they’d had to have a confrontation of some kind???
In summary: All of your complaints about Keyleth are either things she genuinely doesn’t do or things that every other character in the party does on the regular as well.
You can dislike a character! That’s cool! I dislike Vax a lot of the time (not because of his mopiness, as you seem to think) but I don’t make up shit out of thin air to be mad at him for, nor do I fault him for things I’m okay with other characters doing. You can also dislike a character for no reason at all – maybe they just don’t vibe with you – and that’s completely fine.
But maybe it’s worth examining why the things that irritate you about Keyleth don’t irritate you when male characters do the exact same thing and why people feel more comfortable screaming at Marisha than they do screaming at Liam or Taliesin or Sam.